To Top

A Separate Carriage for Women? No Thank You England!

It seems the concept of sexual assault has been lost on Chris Williamson, a shadow fire services minister who recently suggested that female-only carriages might be a decent fix for the increasing number of sexual assaults that occur on public transportation.

The idea had previously been floated by Labor Minister Jeremy Corbyn but was shot down because statistics didn’t support the idea. Corbyn also said, “However, I would consult with women and open it up to hear their views on whether women-only carriages would be welcome – and also if piloting this at times and [on] modes of transport where harassment is reported most frequently would be of interest.”

The idea itself is odd since it would only work towards normalizing the issue instead of working to prevent it. However, Williamson told PoliticsHome, “[The idea] would be worth consulting about.” He continues, explaining why he believes this saying, “It was pooh-poohed, but these statistics seem to indicate there is some merit in examining that. Complemented with having more guards on trains, it would be a way of combating these attacks, which have seen a very worrying increase in the past few years.”

While Williamson likes the idea he also adds that it doesn’t have to be implemented but should at least be explored, after all, “it may create a safe space” for women. He even said women would not be obliged to use these female-only carriages.

Williamson might believe the idea has some merit. However, women-only carriages are not a great answer to the growing number of sexual assaults that occur on trains. Laura Bates, from a website called Everyday Sexism, pointed out that segregating our sexes would only act to further normalize the issue. She said, “It has to be about sending a clear message that this issue, which is already so normalized in our society, can be further normalized by the idea that women should simply go somewhere else.”

In no way should we be putting the responsibility of preventing sexual assault on the women who are being assaulted. The problem lies with the person who assaults her. The Campaign group End Violence Against Women said, “And what happens when a woman doesn’t opt to use a segregated carriage – is she somehow to blame if she is then attacked?”

Women shouldn’t have to separate themselves from men on the train in order to keep themselves from being sexually assaulted on public transportation. Mick Whelan, General Secretary of Aslef, said,It’s up to the privatized train operating companies to make sure every space is safe on every train.

He also added, “That’s their job – and their responsibility. Let’s make all carriages, on all our trains, safe for all passengers rather than restricting where people can and cannot sit. Because we don’t want gender apartheid on Britain’s railways.”
While the idea might prevent sexual assault on public transportation, it misses the point entirely. Not only would it say,we are giving up on trying to prosecute assaults” – as Jess Phillips, Labor MP for Birmingham Yardly so aptly put it – it also does not tackle the real problem, which is prevention. Phillips even added, “Also, men should be incredibly annoyed by the suggestion that they can’t control themselves.”

Featured Image by Justin Schuck on Flickr

Attribution-NoDerivs 2.0 Generic (CC BY-ND 2.0)

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More in Be Informed

  • How to Manage Perfectionism

    Perfectionism can be extremely harmful as well as difficult to manage. Luckily there are ways to cope and improve your mental...

    Lydia SchapiroSeptember 24, 2020
  • Naomi Osaka Advocates for Racial Justice

    Learn about how star tennis player, Naomi Osaka, shows her social activism and support to racial justice on the court.

    Lydia SchapiroSeptember 16, 2020
  • Sustainability at Home

    Cultivating sustainability in the home is easier than you think! Learn about the easy ways to make your home more eco-friendly....

    Lydia SchapiroAugust 27, 2020
  • How Will College Change in the Fall?

    Keep reading to learn about the question marks surrounding the coming semester.

    Lydia SchapiroAugust 26, 2020
  • Egypt Making Strides Toward Equality

    Egypt took a step further in the direction of women’s rights a few days ago, approving a law that would protect...

    Kalyn WomackAugust 21, 2020
  • Black Mothers: The Risk of Giving Birth

    Serena Williams was not the first black woman to be ignored by her doctor post-partum. Black mothers consistently balance the joy...

    Kalyn WomackAugust 14, 2020
  • No More Bumps: 5 Steps to Smooth Skin

    Ladies, it’s hard to feel nice and smooth after shaving when ingrown hairs and bumps immediately take the spotlight. However, not...

    Kalyn WomackAugust 13, 2020
  • Healthy Social Media Use

    Social media presence has increased for decades, remaining incredibly prevalent in everyday life. Cultivate healthy habits by learning about the effects...

    Lydia SchapiroAugust 12, 2020
  • No Woman was Surprised by What Happened to AOC

    A few weeks ago, Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez was insulted by Representative Ted Yoho being called a “f—ing bitch” and “dangerous.” Afterwards,...

    Kalyn WomackAugust 12, 2020
  • The Meaning Behind #ChallengeAccepted

    Recently, a trend has surfaced on Instagram where women nominate one another privately to post a black and white picture of...

    Kalyn WomackAugust 11, 2020